|
Facilitator's Script:
|
|
|
Throughout
the module is a script,
designated by the star
icon, which can be used
to introduce issues,
ask reflective questions,
prompt discussion, elicit
feedback, and summarize
important take-home
messages.
The script can be read
or preferably paraphrased
by the educator(s) facilitating
the teaching sessions. |
|
Time
The
time allocated for this session is 30
minutes.
Beginning
the Session: Introductions
At
the beginning of the session, the facilitator
and learners should introduce themselves
briefly. Ideas for creative introductions
can be found in the introduction to
the Facilitator’s Guide.
Setting the Context: The Bright Futures Concept
The
facilitator introduces the learners
to the Bright Futures concept of health
by reading or paraphrasing the following:
|
|
|
The
World Health Organization
has defined health as
“a state of complete
physical, mental and
social well-being and
not merely the absence
of disease or infirmity.”
Bright Futures embraces
this broad definition
of health — one
that includes not only
prevention of morbidity
and mortality, but also
the achievement of a
child’s full potential.
In the Bright Futures
concept of health, providing
the capacity for healthy
child development is
as important as ameliorating
illness or injury. Recognizing
and acknowledging the
strengths and resources
of the child, family,
and community are essential
to promoting healthy
growth and development.
To
build that capacity,
the Pediatrics in Practice
curriculum focuses on
six core concepts: Partnership,
Communication, Health
Promotion, Time Management,
Education, and Advocacy.
The curriculum also
includes a companion
module (Health) and
videotape that present
an overview of Pediatrics
in Practice and the
Bright Futures approach. |
|
Introducing the Session
Before
introducing the session, the facilitator
distributes the handout Advocacy:
Advocating for Children, Families,
and Communities to the learners.
The facilitator then paraphrases the
following:
|
|
|
Today’s
session is the first
of two that comprise
the Pediatrics in Practice
Advocacy module. Your Advocacy: Advocating
for Children, Families,
and Communities handout outlines the
steps involved in advocating
for children, families,
and communities. We
will cover these steps
in more detail as we
go through today’s
session.
Child
health professionals
have the unique opportunity
to practice advocacy
each day they interact
with children and families.
They can be involved
in child advocacy either
at an individual level
(accessing information
or services for a child
or family) or at a local
or national level (sharing
information with the
community, disseminating
information through
the media, and speaking
out in support of a
legislative issue).
Although the voices
of child health professionals
can have a profound
impact on a child or
family’s ability
to obtain services,
or on local and national
policies, most pediatric
providers lack formal
training in advocacy.
In
today’s session,
our objectives will
be to:
- Define
advocacy as it pertains
to you, the child
health professional.
- Introduce
the four-step approach
to advocacy.
- Practice
using the four-step
approach to advocate
for a child or family.
The
session will have two
parts:
- Deciding
what to advocate for
- Applying
the four-step approach
When
we have completed the
session, you should
be able to answer the
following questions:
- What
are the essential
elements of advocacy?
- How
do open-ended questions
facilitate identification
of child, parent,
or family concerns?
|
|
Discussion and Exercises: Defining Advocacy
The
facilitator distributes the Defining
Advocacy and Other Related Terms handout
and asks:
|
|
|
How
would you define “advocacy”?
Suggest some words that
come to mind when you
hear the phrase “to
advocate” or the
word “advocacy.” |
|
At
the display board or flip chart, the
facilitator begins a list from the
learners’ suggestions. If suggestions
are slow in coming, one or two of
the following can be used to prompt
further ideas from the learners.
Plead |
Protect |
A
cause |
Argue |
Defend |
An
idea |
Support |
Take
a stand |
A
policy |
Attitude |
Belief |
Uphold |
Opinion |
Assist |
Reason |
Debate |
Help |
Sustain |
After noting the suggestions, the
facilitator continues:
|
|
|
The
American Heritage Dictionary
defines “advocacy”
as “the act of
pleading or arguing
in favor of something,
such as a cause, an
idea, or a policy; active
support.” |
|
Deciding What to Advocate For
The
facilitator should now paraphrase
the following:
|
|
|
There
are many ways to define
the term “advocacy,”
but in order to be an
advocate for a child
and family at any level,
the child health professional
must know for what he
or she is advocating.
In the case of an individual
patient and family,
the process begins by
interviewing the child
and family to elicit
their true needs and
concerns. |
|
Gathering Information
The
facilitator continues:
|
|
|
Some
of you may already be
familiar with the use
of interview questions
to elicit a child and
family’s needs
or concerns. For you,
the following will be
a brief refresher. For
others, this will emphasize
a few important points
to remember when asking
interview questions. |
|
The
facilitator writes the following on
the display board:
- All
questions should be nonjudgmental.
- Open-ended
questions support a dialogue between
the child and/or family and the
pediatric provider, and often elicit
the family’s needs and concerns.
- Yes/no
answers can provide important information,
particularly in follow-up to open-ended
questions.
The
facilitator says:
|
|
|
Here
are some questions that
might prove useful when
interviewing the child
and family: |
|
The
facilitator reads or writes the following:
- What
are some of the main concerns in
your life right now? Do they include
transportation? Housing? Personal
safety? What assistance would be
helpful with these issues?
- Tell me about your neighborhood.
How safe is it?
- How
much time do you have for yourself?
Who helps you with your child (children)?
- What
are some of the things you worry
about?
- When
you ride your bicycle, rollerblade,
or skateboard, what protective equipment
do you use? Do you wear a helmet?
- Does
anyone in your home have a gun?
How do you store it? Is it unloaded
and locked up? Where is the ammunition
stored? Have you considered removing
the gun from your home?
- Does
anyone smoke in your house?
- What
concerns do you have about health
insurance for your children?
The
facilitator then says:
|
|
|
Open-ended
questions like these
help to elicit the child
and/or family’s
true needs and concerns.
This is an important
step in creating advocacy
priorities. The next
part of this session
will provide a stepwise
approach that can be
used to navigate the
advocacy process. |
|
Stepwise: The Four-Step Approach to Advocacy
This
part of the session introduces the
four-step approach to advocacy. The
facilitator can either present these
four steps to the group, followed
by a discussion of the case, or can
introduce each step and apply the
case as the discussion moves along.The
facilitator distributes the following
two handouts:
The
facilitator begins as follows:
|
|
|
I
have distributed two
handouts. One outlines
the four-step approach
to answering the question
“How do I advocate
for a child, family,
and/or community?”
The
other handout is a case
vignette. We will use
the four-step approach
to organize our response
to the problem raised
in the vignette. Would
one of you please read
the vignette aloud to
the group? |
|
Using
the display board or flip chart, the
facilitator introduces the first step
in the Stepwise Approach and its supporting
activities:
STEP 1: Identify Family Needs or Concerns
A.
Use open-ended questions to identify
specific family needs or concerns.
|
|
|
Using
open-ended question/comments,
gather specific information
about the learning difficulties
that Taylor’s
mother feels her daughter
is having. What are
some questions you might
ask? |
|
Examples:
- Please
describe for me specifically what
you have observed when Taylor reads
and writes.
- Please
describe Taylor’s teacher’s
assessment of her progress in school.
Have you discussed your concerns
with the teacher?
- What
was stated in her report card or
end-of-year report from last year?
- What
support have you received from the
school’s evaluation team?
- Please
describe any signs of stress that
Taylor has shown lately. Has she
been experiencing any other difficulties
at school or at home?
- Please
describe the difficulties that Taylor
may have paying attention at school.
Have you noticed this at home?
B.
Choose a specific area of focus.
|
|
|
In
this case, what is the
primary problem that
Taylor needs help with?
(reading and writing)
She and her family might
also benefit from someone
to advocate on their
behalf with school personnel,
such as the teacher
or special education
staff.
When
advocating on an individual,
community, or national
level, identifying the
specific problems is
important to making
effective change. |
|
C.
Clarify the family’s beliefs
and expectations about the issue.
|
|
|
What
does the family believe
is the cause of the
problem? What expectations
do they have for Taylor?
What expectations do
they have of you in
helping them address
this problem?
Understanding
the child and parent’s
beliefs and expectations
helps to clarify how
they view the problem. |
|
You
might ask the following:
- What
are you concerned about the most?
- Why
do you think Taylor is having more
trouble with reading and writing?
- How
do the books that Taylor is reading
compare with what other children
in her class are reading?
- What
would you like to see Taylor reading
or writing at this time?
- What
else can I do to assist you at this
time?
- Taylor,
what do you enjoy about school?
- How
do you feel about your school work
this year?
D.
Determine what has been done to date
and what has (or has not) worked.
|
|
|
From
your questions and information
gathering, let us say
you have determined:
- Taylor’s
reading and writing
have not progressed
from last year. In
fact, her mother feels
she is falling farther
and farther behind.
Her mother notes that
she reads very slowly
and is unable to recall
what she has read.
She has difficulty
reading all but the
simplest words.
- Taylor
is not getting any
services through the
school. The teacher
suggested that Taylor’s
issues were behavioral
and not a learning
disability.
|
|
E.
Do some initial “fact finding”
and obtain data.
|
|
|
Your
assessment of the situation
should include gathering
additional information.
You might obtain the
following “data”
or “facts:”
- Attention
rating forms completed
by Taylor’s
teachers and parents
- Taylor’s
report card from last
year
- Her
behavior at school
and at home
According
to her mother, Taylor
has not demonstrated
any behavioral problems
or signs of inattention
at school or at home,
but her attention during
reading declines. |
|
Other
factors that might affect Taylor’s
reading or writing:
|
|
|
You
discover that her
vision and hearing
screening are normal. |
|
F.
Talk with others, determine progress
to date on the issue.
|
|
|
Speaking
with others, such as
Taylor’s teacher,
may provide additional
information. |
|
STEP 2: Assess the Situation
A.
Determine existing community resources.
|
|
|
Based
on the specific need
or concern you have
identified and explored,
the next step is to
develop a list of possible
resources to address
the need. |
|
Examples:
- What
remedial services are available
from the school itself?
- What
are the possibilities for referrals
to other professionals?
- What
might Taylor’s health plan
provide?
- What
other child-focused services might
be available?
- What
services are available in your own
clinic?
B.
Learn the laws.
|
|
|
Is
there a law that covers
what you are advocating
for? If so, what resources
does the legislation
provide? You might want
to consult a local social
worker or the legal
aid society to learn
about the laws that
pertain to the issue
you are advocating for. |
|
For
example, the Individuals with Disabilities
Education Act requires public school
systems to provide special education
services to children with disabilities
who are three years and older. Familiarity
with laws regarding special education
and other services can be very useful.
C.
Review the data and resources.
|
|
|
Document
the problem to be sure
it supports the issue. |
|
In
this case:
- Verify
that Taylor’s report card
shows evidence of a remedial need.
- Talk
with Taylor’s teacher to determine
if he/she might acknowledge that
the problem is not a behavioral
one.
- Ask
for the teacher’s support
in seeking remedial services for
Taylor.
D.
Assess the political or service climate.
|
|
|
Is
this issue of interest
to anyone else (a school
administrator, the teacher,
a local policymaker)?
Who
or what might oppose
you in your advocacy
efforts and why? |
|
For
example, are the special education
service providers underfunded and/or
overwhelmed?
STEP 3: Develop a Strategy
A.
Limit efforts to a specific issue.
|
|
|
While
there may be other patient
or family issues that
warrant attention, it
is best to stay focused
on one area at a time. |
|
In
this case, helping Taylor with reading
and writing is the chosen issue.
B.
Use existing resources.
|
|
|
At
this point, you should
begin to develop your
action plan using existing
resources. In this example,
what strategies might
be used? |
|
Efforts
might include:Requesting
services from the school
- Write
a letter to the school district
documenting Taylor’s issues
and request an evaluation for special
education services.
- Call
the school to discuss Taylor’s
needs with her teacher, and ask
him/her to join in the request for
an evaluation.
- Attend
Taylor’s special education
evaluation meeting at the school.
- Plan
a follow-up visit in your office
after the evaluation is complete.
- Discuss
the findings and the resources offered.
Making
referrals to other community resources
- Explore
the option of obtaining an evaluation
or support at a community based
center (e.g., center for language
and learning or communications disorder
center).
- Refer
Taylor’s family to a social
worker or case manager who can help
the family access services in the
community.
- Discuss
the possibility of Taylor’s
family obtaining support (or an
advocate) from a community or national
support group (e.g., Federation
for Children with Special Health
Care Needs).
Using
the health care system
- Help
the family obtain therapy and other
services through their health coverage.
|
|
|
Prioritize
your action plan based
on resources that are
most easily attainable.
In our example, what
would be the best place
to begin? |
|
- Seek
services from the school.
- Make
referral to other professionals
(this could take time based on
case load and available resources).
- Use
the health care system (the family
may have no or limited coverage)
C.
Start with small steps and build upon
success.
|
|
|
In
what order would you
request services from
the school? |
|
1.
Contact the teacher again.
2.
Write a letter to the school district.
3.
Attend the special education evaluation.
STEP 4: Follow Through
A.
Be passionate about the issue.
|
|
|
Commit
yourself to the problem
or need, but be willing
to negotiate. |
|
B.
Review the outcome.
|
|
|
Keep
abreast of and reexamine
the different steps
in your action plan
as you take them. |
|
C.
Evaluate your efforts.
|
|
|
Reflect
on your effort to date.
Ask yourself the following
questions:
- Have
I addressed the family’s
primary concern?
- What
worked, what didn’t
work, and why?
- What
else needs to be done?
|
|
D.
Determine next steps in partnership
with the family.
|
|
|
Partner
with the family to determine
what the next steps
might be. |
|
Example:
- Determine
how you and the family will track
Taylor’s progress following
your intervention.
- Using
open-ended questions, ask Taylor
and her family what they believe
should be the next steps in providing
support for Taylor’s reading
and writing.
E.
Recognize that child health professionals
and families can learn from one another
about effective advocacy.
|
|
|
Accessing
services for children
and families, especially
those outside the medical
system, can be confusing
for both the family
and the pediatric provider.
You and the family can
learn from one another
about how to effectively
advocate for children
and their needs. |
|
Take-Home Message
The
facilitator ends the session with
the following:
|
|
|
This
session has provided
a basic introduction
to advocacy by defining
it, teaching a four-step
approach to advocacy,
and applying these steps
to a case. I hope this
session has illustrated
how a relatively small
effort on your part
can have a large impact
on a child or family’s
life.
Before
we conclude, what questions
remain about what we
addressed today? |
|
Answers to Guiding Questions
The facilitator continues:
|
|
|
Now
that we have completed
this session on Advocacy,
you should be able to
answer the following
questions:
What
are the essential elements
of advocacy?
- Identifying
child or family needs
or concerns, assessing
the situation, developing
a strategy, and following
through with it.
How
do open-ended questions
facilitate identification
of child/family concerns?
- Open-ended
questions support
a dialogue between
the child and/or family
and the pediatric
provider and often
elicit the needs or
concerns of the family.
|
|
Planning
for the Next Session (if Session 2 is
planned)
The facilitator continues:
|
|
|
At
the next session, we
will apply the four-step
approach to either another
vignette or an actual
case to demonstrate
how to effectively advocate
for the needs of a group
at the local/national
level. |
|
Evaluation
The
facilitator now distributes the Session
Evaluation Form and the Learner
Self- Assessment Form.
The
facilitator also completes the Facilitator
Self-Assessment Form.
|
|